Header graphic for print
The Corporate Observer A Publication by Attorneys Devoted to Protecting Consumer Rights

Monthly Archives: February 2012

Promises, Promises, AT&T Customer Successfully Sues in Small Claims Court in California for Throttling of Data Speeds: Winning $850

Posted in In the Courts

Courageous AT&T customer Matt Spaccarelli had enough. More and more consumers are taking these matters into their own hands. Sounds a bit like Heather Peters and her battle with Honda. Even if Mr. Spaccarelli could have filed a class action, I bet he’s feeling better and surely has more money in his pocket by moving forward in small claims court.

A Day In Court: Lessons Learned About Modern Debtor’s Prison

Posted in Consumer Protection

As Mr. Dickens himself put it, “I was too cowardly to do what I knew to be right, as I had been too cowardly to avoid doing what I knew to be wrong.” Imprisonment for a private debt–I thought it was 2012? We know what’s right; it’s time to change in practice what we changed in the law almost a century and a half ago.

Watering Down the Volcker Rule: The Disingenuousness of the Banking Industry While We Discussed the Rule’s Merits

Posted in Banks and Financial Services

Every time banks asked, “Well what do we do if X, Y, or Z happens,” a contingency was written into the rule. And when asked: “Hey, how is this going to be interpreted,” definitions and interpretations were spelled out. (Okay, maybe not every time. But how on earth did a plan as simple as “No risking taxpayer money on proprietary trading” reach 500 words, not to mention 500 pages?)

Regulating Credit Reporting Agencies and Debt Collectors: Richard Cordray and the CFPB Establish Some of Their Territory

Posted in Consumer Protection

Valuable to many and a safety net to millions more, predatory loans are around to stay. But good news: Our new friends at the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau–for the first time–will be taking a good hard look at what is legalized “loan sharking” and put a national enforcement strategy together for policing these practices.

Citibank to Pay $153 Million to Settle Yet Another Case of Wrongful Conduct: Thank You Sherry Hunt

Posted in Whistleblowers

We commend you Sherry Hunt. Management at CitiMortgage and possibly CitiBank put profits before ethics and the law, but you did not. You saw a crime being committed and you blew the whistle. You risked your job, and possibly a career in banking to simply do the right thing. If more people had your courage and tenacity, financial institutions would play by the rules. They would not have to be hit over the head with a 2×4 wielded by the U.S. Attorney’s Office.

“The lady doth protest too much, methinks…” – Volcker Must Be On To Something

Posted in Banks and Financial Services

It will be okay, big guys. Investment banks will allow for the liquidity you supposedly so dearly fear losing. The market will adapt and the reduced risk in the U.S. financial system will restore confidence and integrity to the markets. The economy grew for decades under the Glass-Steagall Act. Would we really be upset to see that growth again–growth all can benefit from, not just traders?

$26 Billion Dollar Settlement of Mortgage Foreclosure Practices: It’s Not About the Money

Posted in Banks and Financial Services

The Department of Justice, HUD and State Attorneys General are sure proud to have reached a settlement with 5 banks (Bank of America, JPMorgan Chase, Wells Fargo, Citigroup, and Ally) over the abuses in real estate foreclosure practices that plagued homeowners and the banks themselves. Is the settlement a triumph or simply window dressing? I’d say somewhere in between – and thus the very definition of a “settlement”.

General Motors: A Phoenix Rising From the Ashes on the Taxpayers’ Dime

Posted in Banks and Financial Services

Fast forward to April 2010. GM triumphantly claimed that it had repaid its TARP loans ahead of schedule and with interest (well not exactly). It doesn’t take a math wiz to question how GW could go from bankruptcy to paying back the $49.5 billion they had received in TARP funds in just a year. Senator Chuck Grassley of Iowa was quick to pick up on that; GM shuffled its TARP funds, converting a portion of its debt into stock and viola, money (TARP money) was used to “pay back” the Treasury. (“Nice work down in accounting fellas”). In effect, taxpayers were just paid back with different TARP funds not robust earnings. Taxpayers get devalued stock and GM gets to claim it paid back the loans “in full”. But it could have been worse and tens of thousands of jobs were saved

The Two Sides of Carlyle’s Billionaire Founder David Rubenstein

Posted in Consumer Protection

David Rubenstein. Here’s a guy who earned his money, and instead of buying yachts and sports teams and filling the gossip pages with lurid details of affairs with Hollywood stars (not that there is anything wrong with that), he has become a generous and often patriotic philanthropist… But sadly we learned that under Mr. Rubenstein’s watch, Carlyle tried to slip a provision into the company’s soon-to-be-filed IPO documents that would slam shut the courtroom doors to all Carlyle shareholders.

Heather Peters Wins $9,867 from Honda on Claims Her Civic Hybrid Ain’t Getting Promised Mileage Results

Posted in Consumer Protection

Heather Peters’ victory should not only ring loudly in the halls of Honda’s Torrance, California headquarters, but also in every class action law firm in the country. You guys (including yours truly) must do better for consumers–or we will be replaced by the scrappy, take-no-prisoners, make-no-promises “Heather Peters” of the world.